Failure of mainstream well-being measures to appropriately reflect the well-being of Indigenous and local communities and its implications for welfare policies
Abstract
Most current well-being measures ignore the contributions of natural systems in people's well-being. Evaluating the role of natural resources in well-being is particularly important for many Indigenous and local communities to appropriately reflect their well-being and to inform future welfare policies. It is well acknowledged that Indigenous and peoples' values and customs are well integrated with natural systems, and inclusion of these nature-related attributes into well-being measures is required to accurately measure Indigenous/local well-being. This study reviews the available well-being frameworks from global as well as from local Australian perspectives; and proposes a holistic approach to assess the role of natural systems for human well-being using how Indigenous and local peoples' social, economic and ecological values, and capabilities relate to natural systems, that can inform broader human well-being attributes. Both, Capability and the Millennium Assessment Approaches are analysed and applied to develop an integrated framework. This paper emphasises the importance of each connection that people may have with nature to consider for developing better-informed policies on Indigenous and local peoples' well-being as well as on the use and management of natural systems.
References
ABS (The Australian Bureau of Statistics) 2001, Measuring wellbeing, frameworks for Australian Social Statistics, ABS catalogue no. 4160.0, Canberra.
ABS 2005, Measures of Australia's progress: summary indicators, 2005,
ABS catalogue no. 1383.0.55.001, Canberra.
ABS 2010a, Measures of Australia's Progress, 2010- Is life in Australia getting better?, ABS Catalogue no. 1370.0, Canberra.
ABS 2010b, Framework for Measuring Wellbeing: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples, 2010, ABS catalogue no. 4703.0, Canberra.
ABS 2012a, Year Book Australia, 2012: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People. Catalogue no. 1301.0, Canberra.
ABS 2012b, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Wellbeing: A focus on children and youth, April 2011, ABS catalogue 4725.0, Canberra.
Australian Council for Educational Research 2012, Review of the Overcoming Indigenous Disadvantage: Key Indicators report for the Steering Committee for the Review of Government Service Provision, the Australian Council for Educational Research.
Alkire, S 2002a, 'Dimensions of Human Development', World Development 30:191-205.
Alkire, S 2002b, Valuing Freedoms: Sen’s Capability Approach and Poverty Reduction. Oxford University Press, UK.
Altman, JC 1987, Hunter-Gathers Today - an aboriginal economy in north Australia, The Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies, Canberra.
Altman, JC 2004, 'Economic development and Indigenous Australia: contestations over property, institutions and ideology', The Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 48:513-534.
Altman, J, Kerins, S, Hunt, J, Ens, E, May, K, Russell, S & Fogarty, B 2011, 'Indigenous cultural and natural resource management futures' CAPER Topical Issue No. 9/2011, Australian National University, Canberra.
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies 1994, 'Land, Rights, Laws: Issues of Native Title: Issue paper no. 3', in Mary Edmunds (ed.), Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies, ACT.
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare 2011, Health and the environment: a compilation of evidence. Cat. no. PHE 136, Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, Canberra.
Bunya Mountains Elders Council and Burnett Mary Regional Group 2010, 'Bunya Mountains Aboriginal aspirations and caring for country plan',
Burnett Mary Regional Group, Bundaberg, Qld.
Busch, M, Notte, A La, Laporte, V & Erhard, M 2012, 'Potentials of quantitative and qualitative approaches to assessing ecosystem services', Ecological Indicators 21:89-103.
Costanza, R, d' Arge, R, de Groot, R, Farber, S, Grasso, M, Hannon, B, Limburg, K, Naeem, S, O'Neill, RV, Paruelo, J, Raskin, RG, Sutton, P & van den Belt, M 1997, 'The value of the world's ecosystem services and natural capital', Nature 387: 253-260.
Costanza, R, Fisher, B, Ali, S, Beer, C, Bond, L, Boumans, R, Danigelis, NL, Dickinson, J, Elliott, C, Farley, J, Gayer, DE, Glenn, LM, Hudspeth, T, Mahoney, D, McCahill, L, McIntosh, B, Reed, B, Rizvi, SAT, Rizzo, DM, Simpatico, T & Snapp, R 2007, 'Quality of life: An approach integrating opportunities, human needs, and subjective well-being', Ecological Economics 61:267-76.
Costanza, R, Kubiszewski, I, Giovannini, E, Lovins, H, Mcglade, J, Pickett, KE, Vala Ragnarsdóttir, K, Roberts, D, Vogli, RD & Wilkinson, R 2014, 'Development: Time To Leave GDP Behind', Nature 505:283-285.
Cummins, RA, Eckersley, R, Pallant, J, van Vugt, J & Misajon, R 2003, 'Developing a national index of subjective wellbeing: The Australian Unity Wellbeing Index', Social Indicators Research 64:159-190.
Daly, HE 1996, Beyond Growth: The Economics of Sustainable Development, Beacon Press, Boston.
Daly, H 2005, 'Economics in a full wolrd', Scientific American:100-107.
Daly, H 2013, 'A further critique of growth economics', Ecological Economics 88:20-24.
de Groot, RS, Alkemade, R, Braat, L, Hein, L, & Willemen, L 2010, 'Challenges in integrating the concept of ecosystem services and values in landscape planning, management and decision making', Ecological Complexity 7(3):260-272. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ecocom.2009.10.006
Diener, E & Suh, E 1997, 'Measuring quality of life: economic, social, and subjective indicators', Social Indicators Research 40:189:216.
Dodson, M 1997, 'Land rights and social justice' in Yunupingu G. (ed.), Our land our life; land rights - past, present and future, University of Queensland Press, St Lucia, Qld.
Duraiappah, AK 2011, 'Ecosystem services and human well-being: do global findings make any sense?', BioScience 61:7-8.
Grieves, V 2007, 'Indigenous wellbeing: a framework for governments’ Aboriginal cultural heritage activities', Minimbah consultants and education providers' report for the NSW department of environment and conservation.
Human Development Report 1990, Human Development Report 1990, The United Nations Development Programme, Oxford University Press, UK.
Human Development Report 2010, The real wealth of nations: Pathways to human development, The United Nations Development Progamme.
Human Development Report 2011, Sustainability and equity: A better future for all, The United Nations Development Programme.
ICSU-UNESCO-UNU 2008, Ecosystem Change and Human Well-being: Research and Monitoring Priorities Based on the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, International Council for Science, Paris.
IPBES (Intergovernmental Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services) (2019) 'Intergovernmental Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services. URL: http://www.ipbes.net, accessed on 10 January 2019.
Kaur, K 2006, The role of ecosystem services from tropical savannas in the well-being of Aboriginal people: A scoping study, a report for the Tropical Savannas Cooperative Research Centre, Darwin, NT. p. 86.
Kaur, K 2007, 'Linking ecosystem services to well-being: A case study of Aboriginal communities in north Australia', Australian Aboriginal Studies 2:145-147.
Keen, I 2004, Aboriginal Economy and Society, Oxford Press, UK.
Kubiszewski, I, Costanza, R, Franco, C, Lawn, P, Talberth, J, Jackson, T & Aylmer, C 2013, 'Beyond GDP: Measuring and achieving global genuine progress', Ecological Economics 93: 57-68.
Maffi, L 2001, On biocultural diversity: Linking language, knowledge, and the environment, Simthsonian Institution, p. 578.
Malaspinas, A-S, Westaway, MC, Muller, C, Sousa, VC, Lao, O, Alves, I, Bergström, A, Athanasiadis, G, Cheng, JY, Crawford, JE, Heupink, TH, Macholdt, E, Peischl, S, Rasmussen, S, Schiffels, S, Subramanian, S, Wright, JL, Albrechtsen, A, Barbieri, C, Dupanloup, I, Eriksson, A, Margaryan, A, Moltke, I, Pugach, I, Korneliussen, TS, Levkivskyi, IP, Moreno-Mayar, JV, Ni, S, Racimo, F, Sikora, M, Xue, Y, Aghakhanian, FA, Brucato, N, Brunak, S, Campos, PF, Clark, W, Ellingvåg, S, Fourmile, G, Gerbault, P, Injie, D, Koki, G, Leavesley, M, Logan, B, Lynch, A, Matisoo-Smith, EA, McAllister, PJ, Mentzer, AJ, Metspalu, M, Migliano, AB, Murgha, L, Phipps, ME, Pomat, W, Reynolds, D, Ricaut, F-X, Siba, P, Thomas, MG, Wales, T, Wall, CMr, Oppenheimer, SJ, Tyler-Smith, C, Durbin, R, Dortch, J, Manica, A, Schierup, MH, Foley, RA, Lahr, MM, Bowern, C, Wall, JD, Mailund, T, Stoneking, M, Nielsen, R, Sandhu, MS, Excoffier, L, Lambert, DM, Willerslev, E, 2016, A genomic history of Aboriginal Australia. Nature 538, 207.
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, 2003, Ecosystems and Human Well-being: A Framework for Assessment, Island Press, Washington, DC.
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, 2005a, Ecosystems and human well-being: biodiversity synthesis, Island press, Washington, DC.
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, 2005b 'Ecosystems and Human well-being: current state and trends, Volume 1', in Hussan R, Scholes, R & Ash, N (ed.) 'Findings of the Conditions and Trends working group', Island Press, Washington, DC, p. 917.
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, 2005c, Ecosystems and human well-being: Synthesis, Island press, Washington, DC.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), 2011, How's Life? Measuring well-being, DOI:10.1787/9789264121164-en, OECD Publishing.
Posey, D & Oxford Centre for the Environment, Ethics and Society 1999, Cultural and spiritual values of biodiversity, Intermediate technology publications and UN Environment Programme, London and Nairobi.
Prescott-Allen, R 2001, The wellbeing of nations: a country by country index of quality of life and the environment, Island Press, Washington DC.
Queensland Murray Darling Committee (QMDC) 2008-2011, The Regional Caring for Country Plan, Aboriginal Program, Queensland Murray-Darling Committee Inc. Toowoomba, Qld.
Rasmussen, M, Guo, X, Wang, Y, Lohmueller, KE, Rasmussen, S, Albrechtsen, A, Skotte, L, Lindgreen, S, Metspalu, M, Jombart, T, Kivisild, T, Zhai, W, Eriksson, A, Manica, A, Orlando, L, Vega, FMDL, Tridico, S, Metspalu, E, Nielsen, K, Ãvila-Arcos, MC, Moreno-Mayar, JV, Muller, C, Dortch, J, Gilbert, MTP, Lund, O, Wesolowska, A, Karmin, M, Weinert, LA, Wang, B, Li, J, Tai, S, Xiao, F, Hanihara, T, Driem, Gv, Jha, AR, Ricaut, F-X, Knijff, Pd, Migliano, AB, Romero, IG, Kristiansen, K, Lambert, DM, Brunak, S, Forster, P, Brinkmann, B, Olaf Nehlich, Bunce, M, Richards, M, Gupta, R, Bustamante, CD, Krogh, A, Foley, RA, Lahr, MM, Balloux, F, Sicheritz-Pontén, T, Villems, R, Nielsen, R, Wang, J, Willerslev, E, 2011, An Aboriginal Australian Genome Reveals Separate Human Dispersals into Asia. Science 334, 94-98.
Rose, B 1995, Land management issues: Attitudes and perceptions amongst Aboriginal people of central Australia, Central Land Council, Alice Springs.
Sangha, K, Butler, J, Delisle, A & Stanley, O 2011, 'Identifying links between ecosystem services and Aboriginal well-being and livelihoods in north Australia: applying the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment framework', Journal of Environmental Science and Engineering 5:381-387.
Sangha, KK, Preece, L, Villarreal-Rosas, J, Kegamba, JJ, Paudyal, K, Warmenhoven, T, RamaKrishnan, PS (2018) An ecosystem services framework to evaluate Indigenous and local peoples’ connections with nature. Ecosystem Services 31, Part A, 111-125.
Sangha, K, Russell-Smith, J (2017) Towards an Indigenous Ecosystem Services Valuation Framework: A North Australian Example. Conservation and Society 15, 255-269.
Sangha, KK, Preece, L, Villarreal-Rosas, J, Kegamba, JJ, Paudyal, K, Warmenhoven, T, RamaKrishnan, PS (2018) An ecosystem services framework to evaluate Indigenous and local peoples’ connections with nature. Ecosystem Services 31, Part A, 111-125.
Satz, D, Gould, RK, Chan, KMA, Guerry, A, Norton, B, Satterfield, T, Halpern, BS, Levine, J, Woodside, U, Hannahs, N, Basurto, X & Klain, S 2013, 'The Challenges of Incorporating Cultural Ecosystem Services into Environmental Assessment', Ambio 42(6): 675-684.
Sen, A 1993, 'Capability and wellbeing', in Nussbaum M & Sen A (eds.), The Quality of Life, Clarendon Press, Oxford, UK.
Sen, A 1999a, Commodities and Capabilities, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.
Sen, A 1999b, Development as Freedom, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.
Smith, LM, Case, JL, Smith, HM, Harwell, LC & Summers, JK 2013, 'Relating ecoystem services to domains of human well-being: Foundation for a U.S. index', Ecological Indicators 28:79-90.
Taylor, J 2008, 'Indigenous peoples and indicators of well-being: Australian perspectives on United Nations global framework', Social Indicators Research 87:111-126.
The Economist Intelligence Unit, 2005, Quality of life index -The World in 2005, The Economist Intelligence Unit, UK.
UNU-IHDP and UNEP. (2014). Inclusive Wealth Report 2014. Measuring progress toward sustainability. Summary for Decision-Makers. Delhi: UNU-IHDP.
Vemuri, AW & Costanza, R 2006, 'The role of human, social, built, and natural capital in explaining life satisfaction at the country level: Toward a National Well-Being Index (NWI)', Ecological Economics 58:119-133.
Wet Tropics Aboriginal Plan Project Team, 2005, Caring for country and culture - the wet tropics Aboriginal cultural and Natural Resource Management Plan, Rainforest CRC and FNQ NRM Ltd. Cairns, Qld.
Yap, M, & Biddle, N 2010, 'Gender Gaps in Indigenous Socioeconomic Outcomes: Australian Regional Comparisons and International Possibilities', The International Indigenous Policy Journal 1(2):1-29. Retrieved from: http://ir.lib.uwo.ca/iipj/vol1/iss2/3
